For grown-ups
Grab everything in one trip
31 cheap things cover all 25 games. Most of the rest is already in your kitchen, closet or recycling bin.
Party & paper
- Balloons, 12-inch latex · 1 bag (12–24)Day 1: Balloon Chase, Day 7: Balloon Stomp, Day 17: Don’t Pop the BalloonAmazonWalmart
- Dark balloons, all one color (navy, black or dark green) · 1 bag (at least 6)Day 19: Snow or Splash?AmazonWalmart
- Plastic party cups (16 oz) · 1 pack of 50Day 4: Sneaky Elves, Day 10: Yeti Hands, Day 11: Cliffhanger Cup, Day 13: Catch Cup, Day 23: Snowman Cup KnockdownAmazonWalmart
- Small paper cups (3 oz) · 1 packDay 2: Blizzard BashAmazonWalmart
- Paper plates, sturdy 9-inch · 1 pack of 20+Day 18: Paper Plate Skate, Day 20: Ring the TreeAmazonWalmart
- White confetti · 1 bagDay 19: Snow or Splash? (or hole-punch paper)AmazonWalmart
- Sticky notes · 1 padDay 24: Who Am I?AmazonWalmart
Toys & games
- Indoor plush snowballs · 1 set (20+)Day 22: Snowball Fight (or rolled-up white socks)AmazonWalmart
- Pool noodle · 1–2Day 4: Sneaky Elves, Day 25: Pop & BopAmazonWalmart
- Ping pong balls · 1 pack (6–12)Day 9: Tilt Tray Maze, Day 11: Cliffhanger Cup, Day 13: Catch CupAmazonWalmart
- Play dough, 2–3 colors · 1 multi-packDay 9: Tilt Tray MazeAmazonWalmart
- Sleep mask · 1Day 4: Sneaky Elves (or a soft scarf)AmazonWalmart
Craft aisle
- Jingle bells (1 inch) · 1 bagDay 15: Jingle Bell ShakeAmazonWalmart
- Red & green pom-poms · 1 bagDay 6: Elf Sorting Duty (or red and green cereal)AmazonWalmart
- Wooden clothespins · 1 packDay 6: Elf Sorting DutyAmazonWalmart
- Bamboo skewers · 1 pack of 20+Day 17: Don’t Pop the Balloon (grown-ups handle these)AmazonWalmart
- Green poster board · 1 sheetDay 20: Ring the TreeAmazonWalmart
- Felt sheets, assorted colors · 1 packDay 21: Pin the Snowman (or colored paper)AmazonWalmart
- Poster putty · 1 packDay 21: Pin the Snowman (or loops of tape)AmazonWalmart
- Christmas stickers · 1 packDay 20: Ring the TreeAmazonWalmart
- Yarn or string · 1 ballDay 7: Balloon Stomp, Day 8: Ornament Fishing, Day 15: Jingle Bell ShakeAmazonWalmart
Tape & office
- Painter’s tape · 1 rollDay 11: Cliffhanger Cup, Day 14: Toss Tac Toe, Day 19: Snow or Splash?, Day 20: Ring the Tree, Day 22: Snowball FightAmazonWalmart
- Packing tape · 1 rollDay 25: Pop & BopAmazonWalmart
- Pushpins · 1 small boxDay 19: Snow or Splash? (grown-ups hold for little kids)AmazonWalmart
- Paper clips · 1 boxDay 8: Ornament FishingAmazonWalmart
Grocery & pharmacy (the week of)
- Whipped cream · 1 canDay 2: Blizzard Bash (or a dairy-free topping)Walmart
- Wrapped cheese slices · 1 packDay 12: What the Cheese!Walmart
- An orange · 1Day 16: Ornament Elephant
- Cotton balls · 1 bagDay 5: Snowball Nose, Day 10: Yeti HandsAmazonWalmart
- Petroleum jelly · 1 small jarDay 5: Snowball NoseAmazonWalmart
- Pantyhose, clean, any size · 1 pairDay 16: Ornament ElephantAmazonWalmart
Probably already at home
- Kitchen: About 4 bowls, a rimmed baking sheet or tray, a wooden spoon, lots of towels, a blue towel for the “pond”, a broom
- Recycling: An empty tissue box, 6 empty plastic bottles, a tall cardboard box, any cardboard box, a big piece of cardboard, newspaper
- Closet: Socks (6 pairs for Toss Tac Toe, plus a pair for a sock ball), a scarf, a belt
- Around the house: Tissues, 2 chairs, couch cushions, stuffed animals
- Craft drawer: Paper, crayons, markers, a pencil, scissors (grown-ups only), white paint or white paper
- Fridge: One BIG fridge magnet for Day 8. Never small or strong magnets.
Safety while you shopBalloons: a grown-up blows them up. Children under 8 can choke on popped or flat balloons, so throw pieces away right away.Magnets: one big fridge magnet only. Small, strong magnets are very dangerous if swallowed.Day 9 works with a ping pong ball. Skip marbles if you have little ones under 3.Skewers (Day 17) and the pushpin (Day 19) are for grown-up hands.
Store links open a search, so you can pick any brand.